Pardon my Quip?



The other day a patient came in for his six month check up. I noticed an increase in the amount of plaque that seemed to be localizing near the gingival margins of his teeth (as compared with his previous cleaning). After completing his cleaning I asked if he was using an electric toothbrush and he proudly explained he was using a new "Quip toothbrush". I have seen the advertisements for this stylish brush on the subway but haven't tried one out yet. It's design is indeed sleek and modern, but
possibly, it may not be delivering the results its users desire.

Decades ago, I supplemented my dental income by "moonlighting" as a examiner for safety and efficacy studies of various tooth brushes. The best brush that I tested was a braun electric Oral B model. These featured relatively powerful reciprocating brush actions that cleaned really well when used properly. These are now sold by Crest (Proctor and Gamble bought Oral B some years ago) and there are rechargeable lithium battery models starting at around $30.



Some say these powerful brushes may cause recession, but if used properly with appropriate force, twice a day, this seems very unlikely to me. I still use one to brush my teeth every day. Furthermore I personally find it hard to believe that any electric model that relies on AA batteries for power , Quip included,  can compete with the efficacy of the Braun designed brushes that use a lithium ion power source. To the best of my knowledge there are no peer review studies that compare these two brushes for their efficacy. I

I did suggest that my "Quipster" patient perform his own personal study. I gave him some red disclosing tablets and asked him brush one side of his mouth with his quip brush and half with an Oral B electric. Afterwards he should chew two disclosing tablets.  After rinsing and spiting out, this should make the retained plaque visible as red marks on his teeth. He took the disclosing tablet and said he would try out my challenge. I am not sure what the result will be, but it seems a good test for users to see which brush works best.

from Ask Dr. Spindel - http://lspindelnycdds.blogspot.com/2019/03/pardon-my-quip.html - http://lspindelnycdds.blogspot.com/

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Help! My Child is Terrified of the Dentist

Image
If you’re the parent of a young child, you know their brains are similar to sponges that soak up everything around them—especially in their first five years, which neuroscientists say is when they’ll do the most learning and developing in their entire life. At this formative time, your child may amaze you with what they notice: your facial expressions, the different tones of your voice, and your habits. If your habits include regular dental visits and an excellent oral hygiene routine, they’ll notice and want to emulate you. If you happen to feel anxious about your dental visits, or you groan when you’ve got to floss and brush, they may synchronize and feel your dread. This could lead to dental fears that stick with them for years—potentially a lifetime! Kids Can Be Courageous If you’re feeling guilty right now, go ahead and put that away as it won’t serve you or your little one. Everyone has some room for improvement, and Coastal Pediatric Dentistry® is here to help show you an...
Read more

Going for the Gold?

Image
On the left is the older allow, on the right the new one that my lab has chosen to use The cost of a penny weight of pure gold is currently $79.53. The cost of a penny weight of pure palladium is $130.6. It used to be that palladium was added instead of gold to the precious metals often used for pfms, but now laboratories are finding that palladium is no longer affordable. The lab that I am using has just changed the formulation of the metal it's using to one that has more gold than palladium. I really do not mind, but metals with more gold are softer and often easier for a dentist to accidentally polish off delicate margins. It is important when polishing "higher gold" formulations to exert less hand pressure when performing the final polishing of the crown's margins. Other wise there should be no problem with this change. Traditionally labs have chosen alloys with higher gold percentages for optimal esthetics, since alloys with higher concentrations of ...
Read more

Lemon Juice – The Good, the Bad, & the Sour

Image
In a great tale of opposites, lemon juice can be both acidic and basic, or alkaline. Read on to find out why people are talking about this, and what it means for your oral and overall health . What is pH and why does it matter? Drinking lemon juice (usually diluted in a glass of water or added to a cup of tea) is a beloved health tonic among fans of natural medicine. Potential benefits include lower cholesterol, lower inflammation in the body, and increased metabolism and energy. Lemon also contains high levels of antioxidants and vitamin C that boost your immune system. On a scale from 0-14, a pH of 7 is neutral (pure water) while numbers below 7 are acidic (unhealthy), and above 7 are basic or alkaline (healthy). Believers in holistic health blame many ailments on the body’s pH being too low or too acidic. Increasing your body’s pH is called “alkalizing.” Lemon juice in its natural state is acidic with a pH of about 2, but once metabolized it actually becomes alkaline with a pH ...
Read more